# NYC Transit Fare Schemes

In 1930, the Daily News reported that a subway company’s special officers were fighting the “beat the turnstile” game. The turnstile was only the newest target of fare cheats. Since the days of the horse-drawn omnibus, each time New York City’s approach to collecting transit fares changed, people found a scheme to exploit it.

By Lenny Zeltser. Published November 2026. Last updated November 17, 2026.

Source: https://nycfares.zeltser.com/

## Chapter 1. Drivers and conductors kept part of the fares (1873 to 1882)

An omnibus was a horse-drawn coach that carried riders along a city street route. The driver sat on top of the coach at the front. Riders inside the cabin passed their fares up to the driver through a small hole in the roof behind his seat, where he also handed them their change.

The driver worked alone, so only he knew how much money he had collected. As a result, he could keep part of it before handing the rest to his company, a theft New Yorkers called "knocking down" fares.

By early 1874, New York's omnibus companies had installed locked fareboxes in their coaches to stop drivers from keeping fares. Riders dropped their fares into a box that the driver couldn't open. He made change from a sum the company counted out to him. That May the drivers went on strike, saying they couldn't live on $2.50 a day. (By comparison, wagon drivers in New York State averaged about $1.75 a day.) The New-York Tribune said the fareboxes had caused the strike. Before the boxes, it wrote, drivers had (dishonestly) raised their pay to $3 or $4 a day by keeping part of the fares.

> "The drivers admit that it has been their habit to appropriate to their own use fares enough to make their wages respectable."

When omnibus drivers went on strike in May 1874, their companies hired new drivers. The New York Sun reported that one new driver told his riders to hand him their fares instead of dropping them in the locked farebox. He then left the coach and took the money with him. A week later, the Tribune wrote that the new drivers were reportedly "more honest than the old ones, or at least they have not yet learned to steal." By then the strikers had given up and were free to return to work at their old pay, with the fareboxes still in the coaches.

On horse-drawn streetcars, a conductor collected the fares.

A horsecar was a streetcar pulled by horses along rails. Some horsecar conductors kept part of the fares they collected. In 1873, the New York Dispatch reported that nearly all the horsecar companies hired spotters, who rode as passengers and secretly counted the riders. The companies then compared the spotters' counts with the fares that the conductors handed in. Some spotters kept count by turning a page of a book for each rider, a trick that conductors soon detected. In 1882, writer James McCabe reported a claim that conductors often split the stolen money with spotters to keep them quiet.

Several horsecar companies made their conductors record each fare with a counting device.

By 1877, several New York horsecar companies required conductors to carry a bell punch, a hand tool with a small bell and a locked counter. Conductors had to punch a hole in a paper slip for every fare they collected. With each punch, the bell rang, and the counter went up by one. Riders could hear the bell, so they could notice when conductors took fares without ringing it. Each company checked the money its conductors handed in against their counters.

In August 1877, the New York Times reported that conductors at several horsecar companies were opening the locks on their bell punches and turning the counters back. The conductors then handed in less money and kept the difference. A mechanic who had worked for the company that made the punches was showing conductors how to open the lock. In return, each conductor paid him a fee, usually $5 a week. At 5 cents a ride, a conductor had to hold back 100 fares a week from his company just to pay the mechanic.

About a dozen conductors of the Second Avenue horsecar company were fired or expected to be prosecuted for turning back their counters. The Bell-punch Company, which owned the punches, then ordered all of them altered.

Between the chapters: By 1897, boys on the street were selling transfers, the free slips that riders used to switch streetcar lines without paying again.

### Records

- “South Ferry—The Omnibus [New York City],” a stereograph (About 1865): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/loc-1865-south-ferry-omnibus.md
- New York by Sunlight and Gaslight, “The Street Railways” (1882): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/mccabe-1882.md
- New-York Tribune, page 4, “‘Knocking Down’ Fares.” (May 26, 1874): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/tribune-1874.md
- New York Dispatch, page 1, “Petty Stealing on Horse-Cars and Stages.” (August 10, 1873): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/dispatch-1873.md
- The Sun, page 1, report of the first day of the stage drivers’ strike (May 26, 1874): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/sun-1874.md
- New-York Tribune, page 5, report of the stage drivers’ surrender (June 2, 1874): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/tribune-1874-06.md
- U.S. Patent 100,036, “Improvement in Registering-Punch for Railroad Conductors” (February 22, 1870): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/bell-punch-patent-1870.md
- New York Times, page 5, “Beating the Punch” (August 11, 1877): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/nyt-1877.md
- “History of Wages in the United States from Colonial Times to 1928,” Bulletin 604, Table N-12, page 449 (1934): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/bls-wages-1934.md
- Annual Report of the State Engineer and Surveyor on the Railroads of the State of New York, page 1002, the Second Avenue Railroad (Year ending September 30, 1879): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/state-engineer-1879.md

## Chapter 2. Riders cheated with paper tickets (1897 to 1922)

Streetcar riders received a transfer ticket so they could switch to another line without paying again. In 1897, the Third Avenue Railroad, one of New York City's streetcar companies, accused newsboys in Harlem of reselling riders' transfers. Riders gave the newsboys their transfers in exchange for newspapers, a company inspector said. The newsboys then sold the transfers for 2 or 3 cents each, about half the 5-cent fare.

The Third Avenue Railroad took two newsboys to court for selling transfers. The company inspector told the court that newsboys had sold up to a hundred transfers a day in all, the New York Journal reported. The newsboys said a conductor had given them some of the transfers. The company fired several conductors it accused of working with the newsboys.

When New York's subway opened in 1904, riders bought tickets at a booth, then dropped them into a box at the platform gate, where a guard known as the ticket chopper worked a lever to chop up each ticket.

More than once, high school students rushed the gate at the subway's 103rd Street station ias trains came in. They pushed past the ticket chopper, apparently to avoid paying fares, the New York Times reported.

In December 1905, about 75 students rushed the 103rd Street gate while detectives were waiting there. The detectives caught three boys. A magistrate fined each boy $1, then paid the fine himself for the one boy who had no money.

A transit company in Brooklyn posted ticket choppers at its platform gates.

In the evening crowds at the Brooklyn Bridge, some riders of the Brooklyn Rapid Transit Company (BRT) pretended to drop a ticket into the box as they walked past the ticket chopper, the Brooklyn Daily Eagle reported in January 1907. About one rider in ten put a hand into the box without a ticket, according to the Eagle.

The Eagle reported that the BRT's ticket choppers sat low beside their boxes, where they couldn't see whether a ticket went in, and kept working their levers. The BRT reportedly tried posting watchmen beside its ticket boxes, who stopped several riders who hadn't dropped in tickets.

Some subway riders cheated by tearing their tickets.

Some subway riders tore a strip of 10 tickets into 11 pieces and used each piece as a ticket. The ticket choppers accepted each piece as a whole ticket, the Evening World reported in 1922.

By March 1922, the Interborough Rapid Transit Company (IRT) was replacing its ticket choppers with turnstiles. A turnstile was a gate that let one rider through for each nickel dropped into its slot.

Between the chapters: Riders were soon dropping fake coins, known as slugs, into the turnstiles.

### Records

- New York Journal, page 10, “Newsboys as ‘Scalpers.’” (September 3, 1897): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/journal-1897.md
- The Evening World, page 19, “Subway ‘Slugs’ Cheat Turnstiles About $50 a Day.” (March 30, 1922): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/evening-world-1922-03.md
- “Turnstile mechanism,” U.S. Patent 1,578,660 (Filed June 25, 1921, granted March 30, 1926): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/turnstile-patent.md
- Brooklyn Daily Eagle, page 10, “Ticket Choppers Fail to Stop the Dead Beats” (January 10, 1907): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/eagle-1907.md
- Detroit Publishing Co. postcard 9054, “A Subway Station, New York” (About 1912): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/postcard-1912.md
- The New York Times, “Mobbed Ticket Chopper” (December 5, 1905): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/times-1905.md
- The New York Times, public notice of the Forty-second Street, Manhattanville and St. Nicholas Avenue Railway (February 18, 1897): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/times-1897-02.md
- Karl Baedeker, The United States, with an Excursion into Mexico, second revised edition, page 12 (1899): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/baedeker-1899.md

## Chapter 3. Riders and workers cheated at the turnstile (1922 to 1940)

By March 1922, the Interborough Rapid Transit Company (IRT) was finding an average of two slugs, or fake coins, a day in each of its turnstiles. Dishonest riders had dropped them in to avoid paying the 5-cent fare (about $1 in today's dollars). The Evening World put the loss across all the company's turnstiles at about $50 a day (about $950 in today's dollars). Even so, officials said, the company had lost more to cheating when riders paid with tickets.

By December 1922, the IRT was installing turnstiles with a lighted magnifying lens. Each nickel or slug a rider dropped in stayed in view behind the lens until the next rider's coin replaced it so that a platform attendant could spot a slug from 20 feet away, the Electric Railway Journal reported.

In October 1923, Blaine Dorsey was arrested for dropping a slug into a subway turnstile to save a nickel. In court, a man who had once been a lawyer's clerk offered to get Dorsey released if Dorsey paid him. Dorsey paid, but the man didn't help. Dorsey spent more than a month in jail before another court gave him a suspended sentence, the Daily News reported.

In 1930, men and boys on a subway line in Brooklyn were squeezing through turnstiles right behind paying passengers, the Daily News reported. The subway company's special officers arrested many of them. Magistrates usually fined them $2 to $5 for evading a 5-cent fare.

By 1935, riders were paying with slugs on the city-run Independent Subway System (IND).

Riders had dropped 1,600,000 slugs into the IND's turnstiles since it opened in 1932, the Brooklyn Daily Eagle reported in June 1935. City transit officials said the slugs cost the city less than extra guards or coin-inspecting devices would, according to the Daily News.

In June 1935, city officials took the slugs out on boats and dumped them in Long Island Sound, along with guns, knives, and slot machines that the police had seized.

The city checked the money from each turnstile against a counter that recorded every nickel dropped in.

A dishonest IND station agent couldn't open a turnstile's counter himself, so he would report the turnstile as broken to get a maintenance man to his station. The maintenance man would turn the counter back by hundreds of fares, so that the two could share the nickels that the counter no longer recorded.

In January 1939, eight IND workers admitted stealing nickels from the turnstiles, the Eagle reported. The district attorney said about 30 station agents were involved. He estimated the loss over three years at more than $1 million (about $23 million in today's dollars). The chairman of the city's transit board called that figure preposterous. He said he had evidence of a loss of $1,000 at most (about $23,000 in today's dollars).

To keep maintenance men from turning the counters back, the city's transit board was installing a device to seal each counter.

In December 1940, a subway policeman at the IND's Greenpoint station watched a man drop a coin into a turnstile and wait while other riders paid. The man, Chester Madzenski, then bent down to the coin slot as if to kiss it. The policeman arrested him and found that the coin was a flattened penny, which had kept the riders' nickels from dropping into the coin box. Madzenski had sucked the top nickel out through the slot.

The magistrate who heard the charge quipped that "dishonesty in any form is still a sucker's game," the Eagle reported. He sentenced Madzenski to 90 days in jail.

Between the chapters: From 1953, subway riders paid the fare, by then 15 cents, with a token, a brass disc that the city's Transit Authority sold at station booths.

### Records

- “SLUGS USED TO AVOID PAYMENT OF FARES,” an exhibit at the New York Transit Museum (April 13, 2012): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/slugs-board.md
- Daily News, “Special Officers Combat ‘Beat the Turnstile’ Game” (July 24, 1930): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/daily-news-1930.md
- Daily News, page 26, “Slug in Subway Slot Slugs Back; He Goes to Jail” (November 24, 1923): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/daily-news-1923.md
- Daily News, page 2, “Subway Loot Is $1,200,000; City Hunts 30” (January 17, 1939): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/daily-news-1939.md
- Brooklyn Eagle, pages 1 and 3, “8 Admit Theft of City Nickels” (January 17, 1939): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/eagle-1939.md
- Brooklyn Eagle, page 11, “Pennies Draw Nickels, But It’s Sucker’s Game” (December 21, 1940): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/eagle-1940.md
- The New York Times, page 11, “Odd Subway Thefts Are Bared in Arrest” (December 21, 1940): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/times-1940.md
- Daily News, “‘Sucker’ Gets 90 Days” (December 27, 1940): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/daily-news-1940.md
- Daily News, Brooklyn section page 25, “Fish to Get 3 Tons of Subway Phonies” (June 7, 1935): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/daily-news-1935.md
- Brooklyn Eagle, page 1, “Mayor Issues Threat to Gangsters As City Dumps Weapons in L. I. Sound” (June 8, 1935): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/eagle-1935.md
- Electric Railway Journal, page 947, “New York Subway Turnstile on the Market” (December 16, 1922): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/erj-1922.md
- “Slug detecting device for coin controlled machines,” U.S. Patent 1,602,487 (Filed May 6, 1922, granted October 12, 1926): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/slug-detector-patent.md

## Chapter 4. Riders cheated with tokens (1953 to 2003)

On July 25, 1953, the first day that subway riders paid with tokens, some dropped children's play coins into the turnstiles and got through. The turnstiles accepted a play coin because it was nearly the size of a token. Stores sold the metal play coins at their toy counters, 16 of them for a dime, while a token cost 15 cents (about $1.80 in today's dollars).

Having learned of the play coins on the afternoon of July 25, the Transit Authority's general manager spent the night on the problem. By the next afternoon, he had found an adjustment that made a turnstile reject the play coins. Crews began adjusting every turnstile, which was expected to take several days. The Woolworth stores stopped selling the play coins in the city for the time being.

In 1959, the chief of the transit police wrote that fare evaders had dropped "foreign coins, metal washers, pieces of tin, counterfeit tokens" into the turnstiles. By his count, such substitutes cost the Transit Authority nearly $43,000 in fares in 1954 (about $500,000 in today's dollars). Transit police caught many of the fare evaders and seized equipment used to make counterfeit tokens. By 1957, the yearly loss had fallen below $10,000.

Until 1969, riders on New York's buses could get change from the driver when paying in cash. Robbers held up bus drivers for that cash. There were 304 holdups of bus drivers in the first seven months of 1969, up from 109 in the same months of 1968, the Daily News reported.

To end the holdups, the Transit Authority had its bus drivers stop making change in August 1969. Riders now had to pay the exact fare, by then 20 cents, in coins or with a subway token. They dropped the fare into a locked farebox that could be opened only at the bus garage.

On August 31, 1969, the first day of the exact fare, two men held up a bus driver in Brooklyn at gunpoint. The driver, the New York Times reported, "explained that he could not get at the fares in the sealed coin box, handed over $6 of his own money."

In October 1982, Connecticut began selling tokens for its turnpike's toll lanes in rolls of 40 for $7, or 17.5 cents a token. They were nearly the same size as New York's subway tokens, so within weeks, subway riders were dropping Connecticut tokens into the turnstiles in place of subway tokens, which by then cost 75 cents.

Undercover police watched the turnstiles for riders using Connecticut tokens and charged those they caught. The Transit Authority changed some turnstiles to make the slightly larger Connecticut token harder to use. However, in 1985 the Transit Authority was still finding about 100,000 Connecticut tokens a month in its turnstiles.

Thieves blocked turnstile token slots with scraps of paper or cardboard, then stood by. Riders who dropped tokens into the jammed slots found the turnstiles still locked and moved to another turnstile. The thieves then put their lips over the slots and sucked the tokens out. Youths were stealing tokens this way and reselling them, the Times reported in 1983.

One token clerk tried chili powder in the slots to stop a group of youths. A transit police inspector told the Times what happened next: "The kids came back with buckets of water, threw the water on the turnstiles and then threw the rest at the token clerk." Some transit police officers put a little Mace, an irritating spray, around the slots and arrested the thieves whose lips turned bright red, the Times wrote in 2003.

By 1985, the Transit Authority was finding about 250,000 slugs, or fake tokens, a month in its turnstiles. To make the token harder to fake, it introduced a new token in 1986: a brass disc with a stainless-steel dot in the center.

Counterfeiters needed about two years to copy the new token. The Transit Authority began finding copies in its turnstiles in 1988. A man with a metal shop pressed steel centers into brass discs and sold the copies to a gang called The Ministry, which sold them on to street sellers. Police arrested eight of the gang's members in June 1991, after months of undercover work in which a detective bought slugs from the gang.

Between the chapters: From January 1994, riders could also pay with the MetroCard, a fare card that the Transit Authority sold and riders swiped at the turnstile.

### Records

- FBI Law Enforcement Bulletin, pages 5 and 6, “Organization and Role of a Transit Police Department” (April 1959): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/fbi-1959.md
- Three 35-cent subway tokens, a photograph (July 1974): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/tokens-1974.md
- The New York Times, page 1, “City Adjusts to Token Fares; Play Coins Worry Authority” (July 26, 1953): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/times-1953.md
- Brooklyn Eagle, page 9, “Dime Stores Eliminate Toy Coins as a ‘Token’ to Tokens” (July 28, 1953): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/eagle-1953.md
- The New York Times, page 35, “Turnstiles Reset to Bar Play Coins” (July 27, 1953): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/times-1953-07-27.md
- Daily News, pages 3 and 15, “Riders Bright, Unconfused in 1st 15c Rush” (July 28, 1953): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/daily-news-1953.md
- Daily News, page 3, “Rob Bus Driver, Get $6 Exact” (September 1, 1969): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/daily-news-1969.md
- The New York Times, page 1, “Exact Bus Fares Begin Smoothly” (September 1, 1969): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/times-1969-09-01.md
- The New York Times, page 23, “Exact-Change Rule Starts on Buses Here At Midnight Tonight” (August 30, 1969): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/times-1969-08-30.md
- The New York Times, page 1, “Token Unchanged” (January 5, 1972): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/times-1972.md
- Daily News, page 4, “Fighting Fare With Fare” (November 18, 1982): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/daily-news-1982.md
- The New York Times, section B, page 1, “Youths Stealing Subway Tokens by Sucking on Turnstile Slots” (February 7, 1983): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/times-1983.md
- The New York Times, section D, page 3, “The Kiss of Desperation: A Disgusting Practice Vanishes With the Token” (April 8, 2003): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/times-2003.md
- New York City subway tokens, a photograph (2014): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/tokens-bullseye.md
- Daily News, page 5, “TA will slug it out token-to-token” (August 22, 1985): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/daily-news-1985.md
- Daily News, page 4, “Token play that game, says TA of counterfeits” (March 2, 1986): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/daily-news-1986.md
- Daily News, page C10, “Fake-token ring gets slugged” (June 25, 1991): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/daily-news-1991-ring.md
- Daily News, pages 5 and C11, “The Slug Sleuth” (August 11, 1991): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/daily-news-1991-sleuth.md
- Daily News, page 3, “He Raises a Stotinki” (November 25, 1982): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/daily-news-1982-11.md
- Newsday, page 3, “Conn. Tokens Used in Subway” (November 18, 1982): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/newsday-1982.md
- Staten Island Advance, page 12, “T.A. testing device in continuing fight against token suckers” (August 8, 1989): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/si-advance-1989.md

## Chapter 5. Riders and sellers cheated with the MetroCard (1994 to 2018)

In August 1994, hackers met in Manhattan for a conference called Hackers On Planet Earth (HOPE). Its organizers announced that they would try to copy MetroCards and defeat the MetroCard system. "By the end of HOPE," they wrote, "we will have either cracked it or deemed it secure." On HOPE's second day, a transit employee there told the New York Times that he thought the hackers weren't close to cracking it.

The Transit Authority expected that someone might copy a MetroCard's magnetic strip onto a second card and ride on the copy without paying. Each card had a serial number, transit officials told the Times in February 1994, so their computer system could flag a card whose number was used at two far-apart stations within a short time.

At HOPE's session on the MetroCard, a guest speaker told the audience that one man had already gotten through a turnstile with a copied card. The man had recorded the contents of a MetroCard's strip onto audio tape and glued the tape to a card. He was arrested, according to the speaker, after a police officer saw him take out a card that didn't look like a MetroCard.

By 1997, people had found that when a MetroCard was bent in a certain place, a turnstile let a rider through without deducting the fare from the card. Transit officials knew about the trick but didn't act against it for at least a year, because so few people used it.

On a bent card, part of the information recorded on the strip could no longer be read. When a turnstile couldn't read a strip, it asked the rider to swipe again. According to the company that made the turnstiles, the turnstile tried to repair the damaged data when the rider swiped again, and then opened.

In January 1998, the Transit Authority's president said that six bent cards had been used about 50 times each in one day at two stations. The police, who had seen people swipe other riders through and collect money, arrested two of them.

When the arrests were reported, the editor of 2600, a magazine for hackers, called the trick "ridiculously simple" and told the Times, "I couldn't believe it took us this long to figure it out."

The Transit Authority then reprogrammed its more than 3,000 turnstiles to declare a card invalid after two swipes if they couldn't read it, so riders could no longer ride free on a bent card.

After 1998, people found a way to get one more ride out of a MetroCard whose balance had run out. It turned out that the balance was recorded in two places on the card's magnetic strip, as a backup in case one was damaged. A turnstile changed only one of the two at each ride, so a card that had just run out showed zero in one place and its earlier balance in the other. A small bend in the strip made the place that showed zero unreadable, so the turnstile read only the earlier balance and let the rider through.

Some people collected discarded cards, bent them, and swiped riders through for less than the fare, a trade known as selling swipes. In 2003, the Transit Authority said that card benders stole an average of 500 rides each weekday.

New York State made selling swipes a misdemeanor in 2005. In 2009, the state's highest court ruled that a card bent this way was a forgery, and upheld one seller's felony conviction, for which he had been sentenced to two to four years in prison.

Swipe sellers stuffed paper, cardboard, or used MetroCards into the slots of the stations' MetroCard vending machines so that riders couldn't buy cards from them. Some riders then paid a seller to swipe them through the turnstile instead of waiting in line at the station's booth. A police captain said in 2011 that the sellers typically paid for a few unlimited-ride MetroCards and earned that money back by the end of a day.

In October 2011, the police said a man had stuffed cardboard into the machine at a Manhattan station and then offered to swipe riders through for $2. The fare was $2.25 (about $3.20 in today's dollars). He pleaded guilty and was sentenced to 60 days in jail.

In 2018, the police reported 12 arrests of swipe sellers at one Queens station where sellers kept disabling the machines.

Between the chapters: From 2019, riders could pay with a tap of a bank card, a phone, or a watch. MetroCard sales ended at the end of 2025.

### Records

- A recording of “The New York City Metrocard,” a session at the Hackers On Planet Earth conference (August 13, 1994): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/hope-1994.md
- People v. Mattocks, an opinion of the New York Court of Appeals (April 30, 2009): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/mattocks-2009.md
- DNAinfo New York, “Police Arrest Man Running Downtown MetroCard Scam” (October 31, 2011): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/dnainfo-2011.md
- PIX11, “MetroCard hustlers suspected of jamming machines to scam tourists” (November 14, 2018): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/pix11-2018.md
- “Swiping a MetroCard,” a photograph (November 2020): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/metrocard-swipe-2020.md
- “NYCS MetroCard Vending Machine,” a photograph (April 23, 2004): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/vending-machine-2004.md
- amNewYork, “The MTA still accepts MetroCards in the OMNY era” (July 17, 2026): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/amny-2026.md
- The New York Times, “Fare Card Plan In the Subways Exceeds Goals” (February 20, 1994): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/times-1994-02-20.md
- The New York Times, “‘Phreakers’ Take a Swipe At Turnstiles and Nynex” (August 15, 1994): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/times-1994-08-15.md
- The New York Times, “Two Are Charged in a Scheme To Ride Free on Metrocards” (January 8, 1998): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/times-1998-01-08.md
- The New York Times, “Transit Agency Planning To Reprogram Turnstiles” (January 9, 1998): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/times-1998-01-09.md
- The New York Times, “Bending the MetroCard, Breaking the Law,” in the column Following Up (August 24, 2003): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/times-2003-08-24.md
- The New York Times, “Appeal Fails in Forgery of MetroCard” (May 1, 2009): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/times-2009-05-01.md
- New York criminal jury instruction, Penal Law 165.16, “Unauthorized Sale of Certain Transportation Services” (For acts on or after July 11, 2005): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/cji-165-16.md
- DNAinfo New York, “Bronx Vandals Break Machines to Sell Illegal MetroCard Swipes, MTA Says” (October 29, 2013): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/dnainfo-2013.md
- OMNY.info, the MTA’s page for its tap-and-go fare system, as it stood three days after the system opened (June 3, 2019): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/omny-info-2019.md

## Chapter 6. Riders and workers cheated at gates and fareboxes (2019 to 2026)

In 2019, the chief safety officer of the Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) said that people were posing as MTA workers to take riders' money. They wore safety vests, told riders the turnstile was broken, opened an emergency exit gate beside the turnstiles, and took money from each rider who walked through.

A station agent in 2024 and a station guard in 2025 each pocketed riders' cash and let the riders in. After complaints, investigators for the MTA's inspector general confirmed both cases on station video. The agent retired before the investigation ended. The Transit Authority barred the guard from working on MTA property.

In March 2020, the MTA stopped collecting fares on many of its buses as one measure to keep riders at a distance from drivers during the COVID-19 pandemic. When it began collecting fares again that August, many passengers rode for free. They walked past the farebox or boarded through the back door. In spring 2024, the MTA estimated that half of its bus riders didn't pay.

The MTA instructed its drivers not to intervene, because confronting a fare evader could put a driver in danger. For example, one rider who was asked to pay pointed a gun at the driver and threatened the driver's life.

In late 2024, the MTA sought consultants to study why riders skipped the fare and to design campaigns to change their minds. As an example of a campaign that changed behavior, the MTA pointed to Colombia, where "mimes stationed at traffic intersections to reprimand errant drivers and pedestrians halved the number of traffic fatalities." The MTA had dropped the search without hiring anyone by February 2025.

In the summer of 2026, the MTA estimated that 47 percent of bus riders still didn't pay.

In 2023, according to the MTA's panel on fare evasion, more than half of the people who entered the subway without paying walked in through an emergency gate.

Riders often exited the subway system through the emergency gates. People who didn't want to pay waited for an exiting rider to open a gate, then walked in. To get riders to use the turnstiles instead, the MTA experimented with adding a 15-second delay before the gates would open. The MTA reported that 38 percent fewer people entered without paying through the gates in its experiment.

Some people found a way to unlock the emergency gates from the outside. Every gate opened with the same key, issued by the fire department. Over the years, according to the MTA's panel on fare evasion, keys had been handed to emergency crews and contractors. Copies of those keys ended up in the hands of people who weren't supposed to have them. To stop them, the MTA replaced the gate locks.

In March 2026, emergency gates were still the most common way for people who didn't pay to get into the subway. An MTA official said that riders who walked through them without paying made up 52 percent of all fare evasion.

By 2024, riders could pay at the turnstile by tapping a bank card, phone, or watch through the MTA's tap-to-pay system, OMNY. That September, New York City's schools gave students OMNY cards, each meant for one student and good for up to four free rides a day. Within days, students were offering their cards for sale on Facebook Marketplace.

One student agreed to sell his card to a reporter for the New York Post, who posed as a buyer, for $75. According to the Post, he assured the reporter that "once a card was activated, it couldn't be deactivated." To show that his card worked, he tapped it at a turnstile. "Card not accepted," the screen flashed in red. Afterward, the MTA told the Post that it was deactivating the cards that appeared for sale.

In December 2025, the MTA began testing new fare gates at the Broadway-Lafayette Street station. The gates had tall glass doors in place of a turnstile's arm. The MTA intended them to replace both turnstiles and emergency gates. MTA officials said that the Broadway-Lafayette gates would sense a rider who hadn't paid, slam shut, and sound a horn.

Within a month, people posted videos on social media of riders throwing a jacket or scarf across a gate's sensors to make its doors open. In one video, FOX 5 New York reported, a man tossed his bonnet over a gate, after which "the doors swing open, and four or five people walk through as an alarm begins to sound." In March 2026, an MTA official told the agency's board that some riders had managed to get over and under the gates.

By October 2026, the MTA had put the new gates in at 20 stations. According to the governor's office, fare evasion at those stations had fallen by an average of 35 percent.

### Records

- QNS, “MetroCard scammers cost MTA roughly $40 million a year: officials” (December 17, 2019): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/qns-2019.md
- NBC New York, “NYC is One Step Closer to Saying Goodbye to MetroCards as MTA Starts Rolling Out OMNY” (May 31, 2019): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/nbc-2019.md
- Report of the Blue-Ribbon Panel on MTA Fare and Toll Evasion (May 2023): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/blue-ribbon-2023.md
- Gothamist, “MTA to re-tool subway turnstiles to stop fare evasion through back-cocking” (July 17, 2023): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/gothamist-2023.md
- Gothamist, “Like parkour: New Yorkers mull new ways to fare beat at redesigned subway gates” (December 22, 2025): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/gothamist-2025.md
- FOX 5 New York, “Riders find loopholes in MTA’s new fare gates” (January 14, 2026): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/fox5-2026-01-14.md
- FOX 5 New York, “NYC’s spider-man exposes gaps in MTA’s new fare gate system” (January 15, 2026): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/fox5-2026-01-15.md
- Office of the MTA Inspector General, report 2026-05, “Security Guard Company Employee Caught Stealing Money and Misusing NYC Transit OMNY Card” (April 2026, updated May 2026): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/mtaig-2026.md
- MTA press release, “MTA Moves to Implement Blue-Ribbon Panel’s Recommendations on Fare and Toll Evasion” (July 19, 2023): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/mta-release-2023.md
- Office of the MTA Inspector General, report 2025-04, “NYC Transit Station Agent Caught Stealing Subway Fares” (April 2025, updated May 2025): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/mtaig-2025.md
- MTA press release, “MTA Announces Progress on Reducing Subway Fare Evasion” (May 22, 2024): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/mta-release-2024.md
- MTA, “Progress Report on Fare and Toll Collection: Update to the MTA Operating Committees” (April 28, 2025): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/mta-progress-2025.md
- Office of the Governor of New York, “Governor Hochul Announces New Subway Gate Pilot Reduced Fare Evasion by 35%, Unveils Next 20 Stations to Receive Modern Fare Gates” (October 7, 2026): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/governor-2026.md
- amNewYork, “Fare evasion: MTA officials say modern fare gates being piloted are dramatically stopping turnstile cheats” (March 25, 2026): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/amny-2026-03.md
- “South turnstiles E96 IND from north,” a photograph (December 23, 2016): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/emergency-gates-2016.md
- “NYC Kicks Off School Year with Students OMNY Cards,” a photograph (September 5, 2024): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/student-flyer-2024.md
- “Union Tpke 164th St, Fare Required,” a photograph (August 15, 2025): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/bus-fare-required-2025.md
- MTA open data, “MTA Bus Fare Evasion: Beginning 2019” (Updated October 23, 2026): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/mta-bus-data.md
- MTA press release, “MTA Announces Front-Door Boarding and Fare Collection to Resume on All Local and SBS Buses Beginning Monday, August 31” (August 18, 2020): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/mta-release-2020-08.md
- Gothamist, “MTA, NYPD launch enforcement blitz on bus routes with egregious fare evasion” (August 27, 2024): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/gothamist-2024-08.md
- MTA New York City Transit, “Catalyzing Behavioral Change to Address Fare Evasion,” a request for proposals (December 6, 2024): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/mta-rfp-2024.md
- amNewYork, “MTA scraps plan to conduct behavioral research on fare evasion” (February 25, 2025): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/amny-2025-02.md
- Office of the Governor of New York, “Governor Hochul Updates New Yorkers on MTA’s Efforts to Combat Fare Evasion” (April 28, 2025): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/governor-2025-04.md
- New York Post, “NYC students selling school-issued subway cards good for four free rides daily per year for up to $1,500: ‘A STEAL’” (September 14, 2024): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/nypost-2024.md
- MTA press release, “MTA, Mayor Adams, and Chancellor Banks Announce New Student OMNY Cards to Have Expanded Benefits” (July 25, 2024): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/mta-release-2024-07.md
- New York City Public Schools, “Student OMNY Cards,” a web page as it stood in September 2024 (September 14, 2024): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/nycps-2024.md

## Conclusion

From the locked fareboxes of 1874 to the glass gates of 2025, New York's transit operators kept changing how they collected fares, often to stop cheating. Cheaters learned to beat nearly every new way of paying, with slugs, play coins, Connecticut tokens, and bent MetroCards.

The operators didn't always try to stop the schemes, because each safeguard had a cost. In 1935, city transit officials said that stopping slugs would cost more than the fares they lost. More recently, the MTA told its bus drivers not to confront riders who didn't pay, because a driver could get hurt. Like defenders of any system, the operators looked for ways to stop enough cheating without inconveniencing everyone else.

### Records

- “Interior N.Y. subway, 14th St. to 42nd St.,” a film (1905): https://nycfares.zeltser.com/records/loc-1905-subway-film.md
